Words Their Way
Words Their Way is advertised as a phonics based spelling program. However, it is not an example of a structured literacy approach to phonics. Words Their Way is an inquiry based learning approach to phonics, which uses analytic phonics, instead of synthetic phonics. The program emphasizes the use of word lists that the students cut out and sort into word families. In order to properly assess the efficacy of an intervention, we should use a peer-reviewed meta-analysis; however, to the best of my knowledge there exists only one relevant study on the program.
In 2011, Eddy, Et al conducted a randomized control trial of Words Their Way, on grade 2-3 students. The results of this study were statistically insignificant, suggesting a low efficacy for the program. However, more research should be conducted as one study is never enough to assess the efficacy of a program.
Words Their Way does include two evidence-based principles within its program, phonics, and spelling instruction. However, the program specifically uses analytic phonics, which only teaches phonemes through larger word families and not synthetic phonics. This is problematic, as synthetic phonics has been shown to have higher results than analytic phonics. The NRP meta-analysis found a mean ES of .45 for synthetic phonics in comparison to non-synthetic approaches. It is also problematic that the program teaches phonics through an inquiry approach as the NRP meta-analysis found phonics programs with a direct instruction approach outperformed other approaches by an effect size of .48. For these reasons, I do not believe we can call Words Their Way as evidence-based or research-based.
Final Grade: B-
Some, but not most of the principles are evidence-based.
Qualitative Grade: 2/10
The following program principles were essential evidence-based principles: phonics, and spelling instruction.
Written by Nathaniel Hansford
Last Edited: 2022-03-05
Eddy, R. M., Ruitman, T., Hankel, N., Matelski, M. H. & Schmalstig, M. (2011). Pearson Words Their Way: Word Study in Action Intervention Efficacy Study Final Report.
ELL Toolbox. (2022). Words Their Way. Retrieved from <http://www.elltoolbox.com/words-their-way.html#.YhW4XujMLIV>.
-NRP. (2001). Teaching Children to Read: An Evidence Based Assessment of the Scientific Literature on Reading Instruction. United States Government. Retrieved from <https://www.nichd.nih.gov/sites/default/files/publications/pubs/nrp/Documents/report.pdf>.